Your first debate, Lesson 2 of 5

Reasons and examples

About 8 minutes · free

The big question

How do I make my points sound convincing, not just like my opinion?

By the end you’ll be able to

  • I can back up a claim with a reason that explains it.
  • I can give an example that is specific and believable, without making up numbers.

Where this fits: In the last lesson you named your reasons. Now you make each one hold up when the judge asks "why?"

  1. Step 1 · Read · 2 min

    Claim, because, example, so what

    A point on its own is just an opinion. To turn it into an argument, add three things: because (why it is true), an example (show it happening), and so what (why it helps your side). The judge scores logic most, and this is what logic sounds like.

    One Yes point, built up
    1. Phones make it harder to focus in class.

      Note: Claim: the point you want the judge to accept.

    2. Because every buzz or light pulls your eyes off the lesson, and it takes a while to get back into what you were doing.

      Note: Because: the reason it is true.

    3. In my science class, one phone went off during a video and half the room turned to look. We lost the next minute.

      Note: Example: something real the judge can picture.

    4. So a ban gives every student more of the lesson they are actually there for.

      Note: So what: link it back to the motion.

  2. Step 2 · Check · 2 min

    Check: the parts of an argument

    Label each sentence. Some argue Yes and some argue No.

    • Phones should be locked away during lessons.

    • Notifications interrupt you even when you try to ignore them.

    • Last week a group chat kept buzzing in my bag through a whole math test.

    • Students need a way to contact home during the day.

    • Plans change, like a canceled bus or a late pickup, and families need to know fast.

    • When my club was canceled, I texted my mom to pick me up early.

    Put this No argument in order: claim, because, example, so what.

    1. So a ban takes away a tool that makes lessons faster.
    2. Because they let you look things up the moment a question comes up.
    3. In history, we checked a date on our phones in seconds instead of waiting for the laptop cart.
    4. Phones help students learn.
  3. Step 3 · Read · 1 min

    Examples that hold up

    The best examples are specific (a real moment, not "lots of people") and honest. You do not need a statistic. A judge trusts a clear everyday example more than a number you cannot back up.

    Made-up number

    Studies show that 97% of students fail tests because of phones.

    Everyday example

    Think about doing homework with your phone next to you. Most of us have looked up and found twenty minutes gone.

    Why: The made-up number is easy to attack ("Which study?") and it sounds unlikely. The everyday example is something the judge has probably lived, so it lands.

  4. Step 4 · Check · 1 min

    Check: pick the example

    Claim: A phone ban makes breaks more social. Which example supports it best?
  5. Step 5 · Now you try · 2 min

    Practice: an opening with real arguments

    Give your opening again, either side. This time, give each of your two points a "because" and an example.

    A 1-minute opening on:

    Schools should ban phones during the school day

    A good try:

    Tick them off after your speech. Just for you, nothing is saved.

    Practice this speech

    This lesson is free. A practice speech uses 2 credits. You can finish the lesson without it.

Previous lesson

Answer the 3 checks above to finish