Your first debate, Lesson 3 of 5

The rebuttal

About 8 minutes · free

The big question

What do I say when the other side makes a good point?

By the end you’ll be able to

  • I can answer a point in three steps: name it, answer it, come back to my case.
  • I can tell an answer that deals with their point from one that ignores it.

Where this fits: You can now build your own case. But a debate has two sides, and the judge scores how well you respond to the other one.

  1. Step 1 · Read · 2 min

    Name it, answer it, come back

    A rebuttal answers the other side. Do it in three steps. Name their point in a few words, so the judge knows which one you mean. Answer it: say why it is wrong or weak. Then come back to your own case.

    Yes answers a No point
    1. They said students need phones in case of an emergency.

      Note: Name it: fair and short, in their words.

    2. But a ban during the school day does not mean no phones at all. Phones can stay in bags or lockers, and the school office can call any parent in seconds.

      Note: Answer it: the worry is real, but the ban already handles it.

    3. So their emergency point does not stop a ban, and my point still stands: phones in pockets pull attention away in every lesson.

      Note: Come back: return to your own case.

  2. Step 2 · Check · 1 min

    Check: the three steps

    Put this Yes rebuttal in order.

    1. But almost everything a phone does in class, a school laptop can do, without the group chats.
    2. So the learning point is weak, and phones still cost more focus than they give.
    3. They said phones help students learn.
    No said: "Students need phones to reach home." Which Yes reply actually answers that point?
  3. Step 3 · Read · 2 min

    Three ways to answer

    When you get to step two, there are three common ways to show a point is wrong or weak. You only need one per point.

    • It isn't true. "They said teachers can just take phones away. But in practice that turns every lesson into an argument about phones."
    • It's true, but small. "Yes, phones can be used as calculators. But schools already have calculators, so very little is lost."
    • It doesn't stop the motion. "They said emergencies matter. They do, and a ban still lets the office call home."
  4. Step 4 · Check · 1 min

    Check: answer or ignore?

    Yes said: "Phones distract students in class." Label each No reply.

    • Teachers can already ask students to put phones away when they distract, so a full-day ban isn't needed.

    • Phones help students stay in touch with their families.

    • Lots of things distract students, like noisy classrooms, and we don't ban those.

    • The Yes side didn't give a very good speech.

    • If phones are banned, students will just sneak them, so the distraction won't go away.

  5. Step 5 · Now you try · 2 min

    Practice: answer their point

    The No side has made the point below. Give a one-minute rebuttal for Yes: name it, answer it, then come back to your case.

    A 1-minute rebuttal on:

    Schools should ban phones during the school day

    The point you’re answering: Phones are learning tools. Students use them to look things up, use homework apps and take photos of the board, so banning them takes away something that helps students learn.

    A good try:

    Tick them off after your speech. Just for you, nothing is saved.

    Practice this speech

    This lesson is free. A practice speech uses 2 credits. You can finish the lesson without it.

Previous lesson

Answer the 3 checks above to finish