The big question
If both sides make good points, how does the judge decide who wins?
By the end you’ll be able to
- I can compare my point with theirs using bigger, likelier, sooner or harder to undo.
- I can tell weighing from just repeating my point.
Where this fits: You can make points and answer theirs. But some of their points will survive, so now you show why yours matter more.
Step 1 · Read · 2 min
Four ways to weigh
At the end of most debates, both sides still have some good points. Weighing tells the judge which ones matter more, and why. If you don't weigh, the judge has to guess, and they might guess the other side.
Compare your point with theirs using one of four tests:
- Bigger: it affects more people, or affects them more.
- Likelier: it is more likely to actually happen.
- Sooner: it happens right away, not someday.
- Harder to undo: once it happens, it can't easily be fixed.
Yes weighs focus against emergencies Their best point is emergencies. Ours is focus in class.
Note: Name the two points being compared.
Distraction happens every lesson, every day, to every student.
Note: Bigger and likelier.
An emergency where a phone must be in your pocket, not your bag, is rare, and the office phone still works.
Note: Their point is less likely, and partly handled.
So focus is the point that matters most in this debate.
Note: Tell the judge the result.
Step 2 · Check · 2 min
Check: which test?
Which weighing test is each line using?
Distraction hits every student in the room, not just one.
A buzzing phone happens most lessons. A real emergency almost never does.
Better focus starts the first day of the ban. Their benefits come years later.
A hurtful photo posted online can't really be taken back.
Is each line weighing (comparing two points) or just repeating a point?
Phones are distracting. They are really, really distracting.
Even if phones help with research sometimes, the distraction happens every lesson, so it matters more.
As I said in my opening, phones hurt focus.
Calling home can happen through the office, but lost learning can't be made up later.
Step 3 · Read · 1 min
The "even if" move
The strongest weighing starts with "even if". You admit their point might be true, then show yours still matters more. It sounds fair, and it means you win even if the judge partly believes them.
Denying everything
Phones don't help with learning at all. That's just wrong.
Even if
Even if phones help with the odd bit of research, that is a few minutes a week. The distraction costs minutes every lesson.
Why: The weak version picks a fight it may lose. The strong version gives them the small point and still wins the big one.
Step 4 · Check · 1 min
Check: weigh for No
Step 5 · Now you try · 2 min
Practice: a closing that weighs
Give a one-minute closing for either side. Pick the other side's best point, compare it with your best point, and show why yours matters more.
A 1-minute closing on:
Schools should ban phones during the school day
Practice this speechThis lesson is free. A practice speech uses 2 credits. You can finish the lesson without it.
Answer the 3 checks above to finish